Unexplained Infertility: Why Comprehensive Investigation Matters for Male and Female Fertility
- Renee Grandi
- Apr 28
- 8 min read
Updated: Apr 29
Infertility affects around 15–20% of couples worldwide, and among these, a staggering number are labelled with unexplained infertility. This diagnosis means no apparent cause was identified after standard testing. However, modern science shows that infertility is rarely truly "unexplained", and it is often under-investigated or misses deeper biochemical, hormonal, immunological, or cellular factors essential for conception.
Conception is not random. It is the result of a complex, synchronised biological system that relies on:
Hormonal precision
Cellular health
Nutritional adequacy
Immune tolerance
Environmental stability
Oxidative resilience
Disruption at any level — male or female — can impair natural conception, yet unless these layers are appropriately assessed, couples are left without answers.
The Science of Female Fertility: Essential Pathways and Pitfalls
Female fertility is not simply about egg release. It requires a delicate dance between the brain (hypothalamus and pituitary), ovaries, uterus, immune system, and metabolic function. Biochemical disruptions anywhere along this chain can block conception without producing overt disease.
Hormonal Imbalances Behind Unexplained Infertility
Subclinical hypothyroidism: Even mildly elevated TSH (>2.5 mIU/L) can impair ovulation and luteal phase function.
Luteal phase defect: Inadequate progesterone production shortens the luteal phase, reducing implantation success.
Elevated prolactin: Suppresses ovulation through dopaminergic imbalance, even in women without galactorrhoea.
Low AMH or Diminished Ovarian Reserve: Lower egg quantity and quality, even before significant changes in cycle regularity.
Key Optimal Levels for Fertility:
TSH: 1.0–2.0 mIU/L
Day 21 progesterone: >30 nmol/L
Estradiol (early follicular): 110–220 pmol/L
FSH (Day 2–4): 4–8 IU/L
Immune and Inflammatory Drivers
Unregulated immune activation is an emerging frontier in understanding unexplained infertility. Chronic low-grade inflammation disrupts endometrial receptivity, fertilisation, and early embryo development.
Markers that should be investigated:
High-sensitivity CRP (target <1.5 mg/L)
Homocysteine (optimal <8 µmol/L)
Antiphospholipid antibodies (in recurrent miscarriage or implantation failure)
Elevated cytokines (e.g., IL-6, TNF-α) damage ovarian follicles, thin the endometrial lining, and impair corpus luteum function.
Nutrient Depletion and Egg Health
Mitochondria power oocyte maturation and embryo division.Without key nutrients, mitochondrial function declines — reducing egg quality.
Critical nutrients include:
Coenzyme Q10 (ubiquinol form for mitochondrial energy)
Vitamin D (optimal 100–150 nmol/L for reproductive outcomes)
Folate (methylated) and B12 for DNA synthesis and methylation
Zinc and selenium to protect against oxidative stress
Deeper Dive: Female Factors Behind "Unexplained" Infertility
Women labelled with unexplained infertility are often carrying hidden disruptions in endocrine, immune, metabolic, or structural systems that basic testing misses.
Here’s what needs to be investigated in more depth:
1. Subclinical Thyroid Disorders
Even when thyroid markers are “in range,” they may not be optimal for fertility. Thyroid hormones regulate follicular maturation, ovulation, corpus luteum stability, and endometrial development.
Thyroid Marker | Optimal Range for Fertility | Notes |
TSH | 1.0–2.0 mIU/L | Essential to prevent ovulatory dysfunction |
Free T4 | Upper third of range | Supports oocyte development |
Free T3 | Upper third of range | Needed for luteal function, implantation |
Anti-TPO & Anti-Tg Antibodies | Negative or low-positive only | Elevated levels even without hypothyroidism predict lower IVF success and higher miscarriage rates |
Thyroid Antibodies (TPOAb, TgAb):
Associated with higher miscarriage risk
Linked to poorer oocyte quality
Suggestive of subtle autoimmune dysregulation even when TSH appears normal
2. Autoimmune Activation (Hidden ANA and Cytokine Issues)
Women with unexplained infertility frequently have silent immune overactivation.
ANA (Anti-Nuclear Antibodies): Mild elevations are linked with impaired implantation and early loss.
Elevated cytokines (e.g., IL-6, TNF-α) create a hostile uterine environment, impairing embryo implantation and acceptance.
Th1/Th2 imbalance shifts favour inflammation, making implantation less likely.
Testing for ANA, antiphospholipid antibodies, NK cell activity, and cytokine profiles can help uncover hidden immune system obstacles.
3. Uterine Lining and Endometrial Receptivity Defects
Even when ovulation is intact, the uterine lining must synchronise precisely to the embryo for implantation.
Factors impairing this include:
Thin endometrial lining (<7mm mid-luteal)
Chronic endometritis (low-grade inflammation of the uterine lining)
Asynchronous endometrial development
Structural Testing to Consider:
Pelvic ultrasound with Doppler blood flow assessment
Endometrial biopsy if recurrent implantation failure
Low oestrogen, poor blood flow, immune activation, and thyroid dysfunction can all result in thin, poorly receptive endometrium.
4. Hormonal Crosstalk: The Progesterone and Cortisol Tug-of-War
Stress is a major, often underestimated, cause of unexplained infertility.
Biochemistry:
Chronic stress → elevated cortisol via the HPA axis
Cortisol and progesterone share the same cholesterol precursor
High cortisol "steals" from progesterone synthesis ("pregnenolone steal")
Result: luteal phase defect, shortened cycles, implantation failure
Signs this may be happening:
Short luteal phases (<12 days)
Spotting before periods
Mid-luteal progesterone levels are suboptimal at (<30 nmol/L)
Functional cortisol testing (e.g., salivary cortisol profiles) is essential if chronic stress or poor sleep is part of the clinical picture.
5. Methylation and DNA Repair Deficiencies
Methylation regulates DNA synthesis, detoxification, inflammation, and cell cycle control. Suboptimal methylation can:
Impair egg maturation
Reduce embryo development speed
Increase miscarriage risk
Key biochemical factors include:
Low folate (especially non-methylated folic acid usage)
Low B12
MTHFR polymorphisms reduce methylation efficiency
Nutrient targets for egg quality and implantation:
Methylated folate: 400–800 mcg daily
B12 (methylcobalamin form): >450 pmol/L
Homocysteine ideally <7 µmol/L
6. Oxidative Stress and Mitochondrial Dysfunction
Eggs are mitochondria-dense cells, and mitochondrial function dictates fertilisation and embryo development. Oxidative damage from inflammation, poor diet, smoking history, and low antioxidants can impair:
ATP production
Chromosomal segregation
Embryo viability
Essential antioxidants to protect oocytes:
Coenzyme Q10 (ubiquinol form)
N-acetyl cysteine (NAC)
Vitamin E (mixed tocopherols)
Selenium
Hidden Causes of “Unexplained” Infertility in Women Summary
Hidden Factor | Biochemical Pathway | Testing/Investigation |
Subclinical thyroid dysfunction | Impaired ovulation, luteal defect | Full thyroid panel (TSH, Free T4, Free T3, antibodies) |
Autoimmune activation | Uterine hostility, implantation failure | ANA, antiphospholipid antibodies, cytokine panels |
Uterine lining defects | Failed implantation | Ultrasound, endometrial biopsy |
Chronic stress and cortisol stealing | Luteal phase defect | Salivary cortisol rhythm, progesterone |
Methylation blocks | Poor oocyte DNA repair | Homocysteine, B12, folate, MTHFR |
Oxidative stress | Poor oocyte quality | Antioxidant nutrient levels, lifestyle assessment |
Male Fertility: The Missing Half of the Equation
Male fertility factors contribute to nearly 50% of infertility cases, yet men are often poorly assessed. A basic semen analysis only scratches the surface.
Spermatogenesis — the 74–90 day cycle of sperm production — depends on:
Healthy mitochondria
DNA integrity
Hormonal signalling
Antioxidant protection
Poor sperm quality is one of the leading hidden causes of unexplained infertility.
Marker | WHO Reference | Optimal Fertility Target |
Sperm concentration | >15 million/mL | >40–60 million/mL |
Motility | >40% | >50–60% |
Morphology | >4% | >15% |
DNA Fragmentation Index | <30% | <15% |
Low morphology, poor motility, or elevated DNA fragmentation dramatically reduce natural conception success and IVF outcomes — yet many men pass basic screening despite underlying dysfunction.
Male-Specific Drivers of Unexplained Infertility
Oxidative stress: Damages sperm membranes and DNA. (Elevated ROS testing is ideal.)
Hormonal dysfunction: Low free testosterone, elevated SHBG, high oestradiol from adiposity.
Vitamin D deficiency: Linked with reduced sperm motility and morphology.
Heavy metal exposure: Mercury, cadmium, and lead disrupt spermatogenesis and DNA packaging.
Essential Nutrients for Sperm Health:
Zinc (DNA stability, sperm membrane structure)
Selenium (mitochondrial antioxidant protection)
CoQ10 (energy production for motility)
Omega-3 DHA (membrane fluidity)
L-Carnitine (energy transport into mitochondria)
Why “Unexplained Infertility” is Often a Misdiagnosis
The truth is, unexplained infertility often reflects unidentified oxidative stress, hormonal imbalance, immunological dysfunction, nutritional depletion, or toxin overload — not a lack of causality.
Proper investigation must include:
Female Investigations:
Full hormonal mapping (cycle day 2–4 FSH, LH, E2, Day 21 progesterone, AMH)
Comprehensive thyroid panel (TSH, free T4, free T3, thyroid antibodies)
Vitamin D, zinc, folate, B12 status
Pelvic ultrasound for endometrial lining, fibroids, or ovarian reserve
Inflammatory and immune marker screening if relevant
Male Investigations:
Comprehensive semen analysis (concentration, motility, morphology)
DNA fragmentation assay (e.g., SCSA, TUNEL, or COMET)
Testosterone, LH, FSH, SHBG, prolactin, vitamin D status
Oxidative stress panels or advanced sperm oxidative stress testing where available
Environmental and Lifestyle Assessment:
Toxin exposures (plastics, pesticides)
Nutrient density of diet
Alcohol, tobacco, and drug use history
Sleep quality and circadian rhythm health
Key Point: Only 4% normal morphology is needed to pass WHO standards, meaning 96% of sperm can be misshapen or defective, but optimal fertility demands significantly higher quality.
2. DNA Fragmentation and Chromatin Instability
Sperm DNA fragmentation is a critical but often missed contributor to unexplained infertility and recurrent pregnancy loss.
High DNA fragmentation reduces fertilisation rates, increases miscarriage risk, and worsens embryo quality.
Causes include oxidative stress, smoking, toxin exposure, obesity, infections, and chronic inflammation.
Testing:
SCSA (Sperm Chromatin Structure Assay)
TUNEL assay
COMET assay
Ideal DFI (DNA Fragmentation Index): <15% for natural conception, <20% for IVF success.
3. Oxidative Stress: The Silent Saboteur
Sperm are highly susceptible to oxidative stress because their plasma membranes are rich in polyunsaturated fats, and they carry minimal endogenous antioxidants.
Oxidative stress damages:
Sperm motility (by damaging mitochondria)
Sperm morphology (through lipid peroxidation)
Sperm DNA integrity
Common Drivers of Oxidative Stress in Men:
Smoking (active or past)
Alcohol
Poor diet (low antioxidant intake, processed foods)
Environmental toxins (pesticides, BPA, heavy metals)
Chronic infections (prostatitis, ureaplasma, mycoplasma)
Varicocele (increased scrotal temperature and ROS)
4. Hormonal Dysregulation: Testosterone is Only the Tip of the Iceberg
Spermatogenesis is tightly regulated by the hypothalamic-pituitary-gonadal (HPG) axis, involving:
Gonadotropin-releasing hormone (GnRH)
Follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH)
Luteinising hormone (LH)
Testosterone
Inhibin B
Common Hormonal Imbalances Linked to Male Infertility:
Low total and free testosterone: Reduces sperm production and libido.
Elevated oestradiol: Often due to aromatisation from visceral fat, inhibits FSH and suppresses spermatogenesis.
Low FSH: Directly impairs sperm production.
High SHBG: Binds free testosterone, reducing active hormone availability.
Ideal Hormonal Targets:
Free testosterone in the upper third of the range
LH and FSH are balanced without excessive suppression
Oestradiol optimised (not elevated above 150 pmol/L)
5. Micronutrient Depletions
Micronutrient insufficiency directly impacts sperm development, DNA integrity, mitochondrial energy production, and membrane fluidity.
Critical Nutrients for Male Fertility:
Nutrient | Role | Optimal Fertility Function |
Zinc | DNA stability, sperm motility, and testosterone production | Essential for fertilisation potential |
Selenium | Antioxidant defence in sperm mitochondria | Enhances motility and morphology |
CoQ10 | Mitochondrial ATP production for motility | Increases progressive motility |
Omega-3 DHA | Sperm membrane fluidity | Improves fertilisation capacity |
Carnitine | Fatty acid transport into mitochondria | Boosts sperm energy and motility |
Vitamin C and E | Reduces ROS damage | Protects DNA and membrane lipids |
6. Environmental and Lifestyle Impacts
Environmental and lifestyle factors can silently impair spermatogenesis over time.
Key contributors include:
Exposure to BPA, phthalates, pesticides
Heavy metal accumulation (lead, cadmium, mercury)
High scrotal temperatures (hot baths, laptops on lap)
Sleep deprivation
High-stress lifestyles (raising cortisol and oxidative stress)
Even moderate reductions in oxidative stress and environmental exposures can improve semen parameters by 20–40% over a 3–6 month period.
Conclusion: Fertility is a Reflection of Total Biological Integrity
The term “unexplained infertility” often reflects gaps in investigation rather than a genuine absence of cause. Fertility is a finely tuned biological process that demands synchrony between hormonal regulation, immune balance, mitochondrial function, DNA integrity, and environmental resilience.
Both male and female partners bring critical biological contributions to conception. Subtle hormonal imbalances, hidden immune activation, oxidative stress, nutritional depletions, environmental toxin exposures, or DNA fragmentation often lie beneath the surface — invisible to basic screening but profoundly impactful at the cellular level.
Science now confirms:
Subclinical thyroid dysfunction and autoimmune markers impair female fertility even when routine thyroid panels appear normal.
Oxidative stress, poor mitochondrial function, and silent DNA damage sabotage male fertility despite "normal" semen parameters.
Nutritional insufficiencies, especially in antioxidants, B vitamins, zinc, selenium, and vitamin D, remain underestimated obstacles to natural conception.
By moving beyond surface-level testing and investigating fertility through a comprehensive biochemical, hormonal, immune, and lifestyle lens, the actual barriers to conception can often be identified and corrected.
For couples labelled with unexplained infertility, this deeper investigation offers hope. Hope not just for conception, but for healthier pregnancies, healthier children, and a healthier future.
Comments